Common Wealth Murals

Community and Economic Impact Study of Fresh Paint Springfield Mural Festival

Common Wealth Murals creates exceptional murals that meaningfully engage and uplift the community. CWM manages a Community Mural Training Institute, mural festivals, and curated mural installations.

Granby, MA  |

"Hiring Broadsight to do an evaluation was one of the best professional decisions I’ve made.

I learned so much from working with Jessica and have used her evaluation report to leverage funding and new contracts countless times. Just this morning I was presenting at a conference of city planners and foundations and I mentioned her evaluation and after that, her report was all they wanted to know about."

Britt Ruhe, Founder & CEO, Commonwealth Murals, Amherst, MA

Task: Demonstrate the credibility of Fresh Paint Springfield (FPS) 2019, the first mural festival in western Massachusetts.

Solution: Conduct an evaluation to assess the impact of the festival on the local economy, community experience, and perceptions of the city.

Process: Online and street survey data collection, interviews with muralists and residents, and economic analysis of resulting business revenue.

Outcome: We helped model the first impact study of its kind to measure community and economic benefits of urban murals. We created a 2019 evaluation report written with UMass Design Center, which expanded CWM’s understanding of strategies, efficacy, and impact. CWM disseminated the report widely to funders and hundreds of stakeholders around the nation via conferences and marketing correspondence. The impact study legitimized and put CWM on the map nationally and internationally as a pioneer in mural production and mural festival management, with commitment to data-driven efficacy and community engagement. Further, the program evaluation contributed to fundraising capacity, successful marketing, and acquisition of future festival, training, and installation contracts, including 4-year funding to support FPS.


Broadsight conducted a follow up evaluation of the 2021 festival, focusing on CWM's Community Mural Institute. As CWM’s external evaluator, Broadsight will conduct ongoing evaluative studies of the organization's future programs and work with community engaged muralism.

Our program evaluation work with CWM garnered interest from the Journal of the American Planning Association, the premier peer reviewed publication for international scholars of planning.  JAPA recently published an article by the 2019 study’s co-authors Lara S. Furtado, PhD and Broadsight founder, Jessica M. Payne, PhD, Inclusive Creative Placemaking Through Participatory Mural Design in Springfield, MA explores the role of murals in fostering neighborhood and community belonging.

Other Case Studies

Amherst College seal in lavender on a dark purple background

Amherst College

Mixed Methods Assessment with Amherst College’s Loeb Center

Brothers@ logo


Alumni Impact Study

Stop Hazing logo


Strategic Development of the Hazing Prevention Consortium and Hazing Prevention Framework

Treehouse Foundation

Intergenerational Community Framework

Trust Transfer Project

Impact Evaluation: Engaging Artists and Organizations in Public Health Messaging on COVID-19


Strategies to Improve Undergraduate Success